Restaurant & Hospitality Order › Butterscotch Image 1 of 1 Butterscotch from $17.00 Our house-made brown sugar caramel flavors this ice cream that has its roots in Victorian England. A classic flavor with real staying power. Size: Select Size 2.5 Gallon box 1/2 Gallon tub Quantity: Add To Cart Added! Our house-made brown sugar caramel flavors this ice cream that has its roots in Victorian England. A classic flavor with real staying power.